Supplement V Carcosa Pdf PrinterThe Alexandrian » Review: Carcosa. Part of my general dissatisfaction with Geoffrey Mc. Since rpgnow didn't have the pdf I did a quick search and found: Supplement V: CARCOSA available in both print and PDF! Geoffrey McKinney's CARCOSA (Includes purchasing instructions.) Now I understand why people are upset. Now show us your Supplement VI. Here you can find carcosa shared files. Download Supplement V CARCOSA consecutive pages pdf mediafire Ancient Rites Dim Carcosa 2001 rar crocko free from TraDownload. Posted by Halloween Jack Original SA post. In 2008, some guy named Geoffrey C. McKinney released a PDF work he called Supplement V: Carcosa. What's with that title? Kinney’s Carcosa is certainly due to a difference of opinion when it comes to methodology. First, whether we’re talking hex keys or dungeon keys, I’m extremely skeptical of key entries that consist of nothing more than a list of monsters. This is particularly true of published products, and yet a depressingly huge number of Carcosa’s key entries consist entirely of things like “1. Diseased Guardians”, “1. Mummies”. It’s bland and it’s boring. Carcosa s a weird science-fantasy horror setting compatible with traditional fantasy role-playing games. Carcosa s a weird science-fantasy horror setting compatible with. In the PDF version of the book. Carcosa was originally released as a stapled booklet entitled Dungeons & Dragons Supplement V: Carcosa. I haven’t encountered another D&D supplement structured this way. A review of the Carcosa book and PDF First, I'm going to show you the physical product, available for purchase here, via a. Carcosa was presented as such a supplement when it first came out a couple years. ADDITIONAL Rules for Fantastic Medieval Wargames Campaigns Playable with Paper and Pencil And Miniature Figures SUPPLEMENT The Age of COnan BY JASON VEY NOT Published by TSR RULES Price $0.00. 17 Responses to “Review: Carcosa. Carcosa: Supplement V + The Carcosan Grimoire works for me. It’s also virtually useless. Unfortunately, this generally remains true of Carcosa. For example, massive chunks of the book consist of, “. For example, hex 2. A Brown Man, dressed in immaculate white robes fringed with golden embroidery, rests quietly by the side of the path. He acknowledges with a barely perceptible nod. It would be wise to return this show of respect with a dignified bow or curtsy.? He’ll shed his skin and reveal himself to be a Spawn of Shub- Niggurath? He’ll turn out to be a demi- god? He’ll betray them to their worst enemies? The argument can, of course, be made that the purpose of the key is merely to serve as a creative seed for the GM. But, if so, why is Mc. Kinney so delightfully enamored with the words “cannot” and “never”? Let’s proffer hex 2. Drums, the clash of war cymbals, and the deep clangor of a mighty gong can be heard coming from the desert. The sounds taper and crescendo with the bluster of the wind, but their source can never be found. Even if this wasn’t the umpteenth time I’d read some variation of “there are mysterious sounds and you can never figure out what they are“, you can’t try to defend half the hex entries by saying “just ideas to develop” while the other half of your hexes are trying to stifle the development of those ideas. I recognize that many of these elements are historic qualities of classic hex- based supplements like the Wilderlands. But Carcosa is a particularly bland and repetitive instantiation of the form, and I also think 1. Similarly, while I may find Palace of the Vampire Queen a fascinating historical oddity and revolutionary for its time, anybody trying to sell me a dungeon designed like that today is not going to win my applause. TO THE GOODOne point of particular interest in Carcosa are the sorcerous rituals. These have received a good deal of attention because many of them require specific vile acts in order to perform them (murder, rape, and so forth), but that’s largely a tempest in a teapot. If rape or violence against children are trigger words for you, you should probably avoid this book. Otherwise, you’ll find more graphic stuff in a Clive Barker, Jacqueline Carey, or Stephen King novel.) What I actually find interesting about the sorcerous rituals is that they provide an innovative method for motivating and directing the exploration of the hex map. For example, the Approach of the Farthest Rim, “can be performed only in the lost fane in hex 2. Whether the PCs are trying to stop a sorcerer performing this ritual or playing villains attempting to complete the ritual for themselves, this kind of specificity will drive them out into the wilderness of Carcosa: They have to find that fane. In fact, even if the ritual is not being performed (by the bad guys or the PCs), learning the details of the ritual inherently provides a hook: What else might be inside the fane? That’s a clever structure for delivering scenario hooks and I’ll almost certainly be lifting it in the future. In a similar vein of derived utility, the random charts for Spawn of Shub- Niggurath, Space Alien Armament, Random Robots, and Mutations are all fairly well done. All of this, unfortunately, is fairly brief in character and scarcely justifies the purchase price for Carcosa. Which regrettably brings us. The book bills itself as a “Weird Science- Fantasy Horror Setting” and I was expecting a creative burst of the unique, the bizarre, and the alien. What I got instead was “9 Tyrannosaurus Rexes”. Basically, the book starts by detailing a lengthy system in which you use a d. If you squint hard enough, you can almost have this make sense for Hit Dice (which Mc. Kinney has you re- roll at the beginning of every combat), but when he goes on to do the same thing with weapon damage (so that every time you make an attack you roll one of every die type and then use the d. Unfortunately, you won’t be quick enough to avoid the next page where he lays out the statistical analysis which demonstrates that, on average, all of this extra complexity and dice rolling has virtually no effect whatsoever. And then there’s a whole related mechanic where you have to keep track of multiple hit point totals for each character. Virtually every keyed encounter in the book is aimed at mid- to- high level play. Despite being specifically and explicitly aimed at 1st level characters, this module includes random encounters with 1. HD monsters. If you follow the standard hexcrawling practice of automatically triggering the keyed encounter when the group enters a hex, anybody who strays too far north during the intro adventure is going to get TPK’ed.)IN SUMMARYThere’s really no question that Carcosa is a truly gorgeous volume. Lamentations of the Flame Princess have lavished the volume with fantastic illustrations by Rich Longmore; the paper is thick and luxurious; the binding is superb; the layout and cross- referencing are superb. Most of the book is nothing more than rote mediocrity, large chunks of the rest are unusable in any form, and, when all is said and done, you will come away with nothing more than a dozen or so decent ideas that might be useful if you polish them up a bit. That’s a good showing for a blog post, but for a $4. It’s a disappointment. Style: 5. Substance: 2.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorWrite something about yourself. No need to be fancy, just an overview. Archives
December 2016
Categories |